In a divorce case, there is often concern over how the marital property will be divided between the spouses. Understanding how Texas approaches marital property and its division in a divorce can help simplify the process and relieve some of the stress that comes with not knowing what to expect during divorce proceedings. This article will provide insight into divorce laws in Texas regarding property and help prepare you to understand how marital property is divided and affected by the divorce process.y.
Texas follows the community property model for property division in a divorce. This means that all marital assets acquired by either party during the marriage are considered to be owned equally by the parties and, therefore, must be divided in a just and equitable manner between the two spouses upon divorce. Tex. Fam. Code § 3.002. It does not matter if the property is held in only one spouse’s name—if it was acquired during the marriage, it is presumed to be community property and subject to division of community property. Tex. Fam. Code § 3.003(a). This includes financial accounts and all income earned during the marriage, retirement benefits and retirement account contributions, and long-term investments, among other assets. Additionally, marital debts incurred during the marriage are considered community debts, and treated like community property. The only exceptions to the community property law are assets that qualify as separate property.
Separate property is property that was owned by one spouse prior to the marriage or acquired by only one of the spouses during the marriage by gift, inheritance, or personal injury settlement (except for any recovery for loss of earning capacity during the marriage). Separate property does not fall under community properties. Tex. Fam. Code § 3.001. Any asset that can be proven to be a separate asset by clear and convincing evidence will remain the separate property of the owner spouse and is not subject to division of property in a divorce. Tex. Fam. Code § 3.003(b).
A request to confirm your separate property must be included in your divorce process pleadings before you can be awarded an asset as your separate property in the final divorce decree.
While community property is divided in a just and right manner in a divorce, separate property belongs to the spouse who acquired it, and it is not subject to property division in a divorce. An issue may arise, though, when separate and community properties are combined in such a way that it becomes difficult to determine the nature of any property involved. This concept is known as comingling. If there is truly no way to parse through the history of the asset and determine which portions are community property and which are separate property, then the community property presumption would control and allow for division of property. Tex. Fam. Code § 3.003(a).
The separate property of a spouse can be converted into community property during a marriage, thereby subjecting it to a fair and equitable division in the divorce, according to divorce law in Texas regarding property. In order to convert the property, the spouses must both sign an agreement that identifies the property being converted and specifies that the property is being converted to the spouse’s community property. Tex. Fam. Code § 4.203(a). That written agreement would stand as proof in your divorce that one spouse’s separate property was, in fact, converted to community property during the marriage. Absent an agreement, or some other form of pre- or post-marital agreement, it would be very difficult to prove conversion of separate property. Simply transferring one spouse’s separate property into the other spouse’s name, or into both spouses’ names jointly, like in the instance of a car title or real property deed, is not sufficient convincing evidence to convert the property to community property. Tex. Fam. Code § 4.203(b).
When one marital estate (the community estate or one spouse’s separate estate) pays for or contributes funds toward an asset that belongs to another marital estate, then the paying estate may seek a reimbursement for the amounts paid to the other estate. This definition may be confusing, so the following example is presented to better illustrate this concept:
Wife owned a house before marriage. Once married, Husband moves into Wife’s house and they choose to make it their marital residence. The spouses have a joint bank account from which they pay their mortgage and, over time, use to build an addition onto the home and do some renovations. Wife transfers the title of the home to include Husband’s name with her own, but they do not make any formal, signed agreements regarding the house. After many years, Husband files for divorce. How is the house treated, and what should they do about all the money used to pay for the mortgage and improvements over the years?
The house is Wife’s separate property. The amounts paid towards the mortgage, for the addition and all renovations are community property. Since the community estate paid for an asset of Wife’s separate estate, the community estate may seek a reimbursement from Wife’s separate estate for the total amount it paid to benefit the house (namely, the mortgage and improvements). If receipts and other evidence can prove the payments, then Wife’s separate estate shall reimburse the community estate for all funds paid to it, and that reimbursement goes to the community estate, which is then subject to a fair and equitable division between the parties.
While this is a simplistic example, it helps to illustrate how reimbursement’s work in a Texas divorce. A reimbursement claim must be included in your pleadings in order to be awarded in the divorce, so it is best to seek the help of a divorceattorney to ensure that this is done properly, among many other required processes covered by the basics of divorce in Texas.
Under Texas law, when one spouse transfers community property to or spends community funds on someone or something outside of the marriage without the other spouse’s approval or, sometimes, knowledge, with the purpose of depriving the other spouse of the use and enjoyment of the assets involved in the transaction, the transferring spouse has committed what is known as “fraud on the community.” As per divorce laws in Texas regarding property, a spouse must prove either “actual fraud” or “constructive fraud” to win a claim for fraud on the community in a divorce.
“Actual fraud” is proven by showing the trial court that the other spouse transferred community property for the primary purpose of depriving the alleging spouse of the property through dishonesty or with an intent to deceive. The alleging spouse has the burden of proof to show convincing evidence that the offending spouse acted dishonestly or with the intent to deceive him or her.
“Constructive fraud” is a bit more complicated, and must include a showing that the offending spouse has breached their fiduciary duty to the alleging spouse in some way. A fiduciary duty is a legal obligation to act in the best interest of another person who, in the instance of a divorce, would be the other spouse. In the case of Schlueter v. Schlueter, the Texas Supreme Court ruled that there is unquestionably a fiduciary relationship owed by the spouses to each other and to the management of the community estate. Schlueter v. Schlueter, 975 S.W.2d 584 [Tex. 1998]. In situations of constructive fraud, the burden of proof transfers from the alleging spouse to the offending spouse, who must show that the transfers of property and/or funds were fair and justified.
If the offending spouse did, in fact, commit fraud on the community, then how is the community estate divided in a just and right manner? Texas Family Code § 7.009 is very clear on the remedial options available to the alleging spouse, which mostly involve reconstituting the estate in order to award the alleging spouse a just and right division of property. Here is how the Family Code dictates fraud on the community must be treated (Tex. Fam. Code § 7.009):
If the judge determines that a spouse has committed actual or constructive fraud on the community, the court shall:
In making a just and right division of the reconstituted estate, the court may grant any legal or equitable relief necessary to accomplish a just and right division, including:
In addition to the above remedies, the judge may consider one spouse’s fraud on the community when making a spousal maintenance determination. Tex. Fam. Code §8.052(6).
In a no-fault divorce decree, the court shall order the division of the estate of the parties in a manner that the court deems is “just and right”. Tex. Fam. Code § 7.001. This means that the judge must divide the community estate in a fair and equitable way, while any separate property stays with its owner and is not subject to any property division.
An exception to the “just and right” division of the community estate exists when fault grounds are proven in a divorce or there has been fraud on the community, both of which allow the court to award a disproportionate share of the community estate to the wronged spouse. As a reminder, fault grounds include the following:
The last two in the list are unlikely to cause the court to award a disproportionate share of the community estate to one spouse over the other, although it is still a possibility depending on the specific circumstances of each matter. The remedies for fraud on the community are outlined above and awarding a disproportionate share of the community to the wronged spouse is a clear remedy in those situations.
A final decree should outline when and how the awarded property division should be facilitated. Usually, the divorce decree will include a deadline (for example, within thirty days from the date the Judge signs the decree), by which all property must be given to the spouse to which it was awarded. If the parties are unable to agree to a plan for each party to obtain any awarded property that is not in their possession, then they may ask the judge to order a more detailed manner for the completion of division of community property.
Note that, for common law marriages, divorce laws in Texas regarding property follow many of the same rules and regulations.
As part of the attorney-client relationship, a knowledgeable and experienced attorney can help you transfer titles and ownership documents for motor vehicles of any kind and real estate property, if needed, that will require additional documents that may need to be filed with the appropriate government offices to make the transfers official.
Contact the legal team at Ball Morse Lowe, PLLC, to learn more about how our divorce attorneys can help with managing marital property and community property division. After filing for divorce and going through divorce proceedings, you want to still keep your possessions and hold onto assets that are yours. Our experienced attorneys can help ensure that you will still rightfully possess your personal property while negotiating equitable distribution of community property post-divorce.
Learn more about how our knowledgeable lawyers can help you by contacting us.
The information and material in this article is for informational purposes only and is not intended as a substitute for legal advice.